"Give to Caesar what is Caesar's" and the binary trap- Matt 22
Matthew 22: 15-22 Our gospel reading begins with the Pharisees plotting how to “entangle [Jesus] in his words”. So, they come up with a very clever trap that forces him into a binary: either he picks option A and there are undesirable consequences, or he picks B and there are undesirable consequences. Picking either A or B is going to be undesirable. The Pharisees are no friends of the Herodians, but since Jesus is a common enemy to both, they found a way to work together. So representatives of both groups come to Jesus with a trick question. The Herodians were a faction at the time that was loyal to King Herod, and they wanted to play nice with Rome. King Herod embarked on numerous impressive building projects, which included building cities for the pagan population living in the area. Herod even erected a golden eagle at the entrance of the temple, which was a symbol of Rome’s dominion. He also spent lavishly on gifts for Roman officials. The Herodians embraced this as the practical ...